
|
"Two childlike anarchists with a fine disdain for narrative structure, Burton and Carroll on paper look like a perfect
match. But despite touches of brilliance, this Alice in Wonderland is more a corporate product than a personal statement.
Though the rote fantasy plot holds little interest, visually Burton remains at the top of his game, aided by Colleen
Atwood's witty costumes, Robert Stromberg's evocative production design, and the work of countless gifted animators.
3 STARS." Jake Wilson THE AGE "Burton and his screenwriter, Linda Woolverton, have taken a twisted tale and twisted it some more to create an astonishing and magical movie full of surprises and fantastic characters." Pete Hammond BOXOFFICE "The disappointment is that Burton's visual firepower and vivid characterization [are] being used in the service of a narrative that grows increasingly one-dimensional and simple-minded. By the final showdown, we could be back in the world of Oz or in the latest Narnia adventure." Geoffrey Macnab LONDON INDEPENDENT "The look of the film is terrific, and Colleen Atwood's costumes are a delight. Atwood has won two Oscars already, for "Chicago "and "Memoirs Of A Geisha". These are her finest yet. Is Alice in Wonderland worth seeing? Yes, because it's a feast for the eyes. But the story needed to be more imaginative and involving for this to become a massive hit, and it's not obvious whether it's aimed at children or adults. Tim Burton fails to pull a rabbit out of his hat. 3 STARS." Chris Tookey UK DAILY MAIL "In theory, the combination of Lewis Carroll’s widely popular novels, imagist Tim Burton as director, Johnny Depp as the Mad Hatter, and innovative 3D technology spells magic for Disney’s new version of "Alice in Wonderland", and in individual sequences, the movie soars to Hollywood’s highest level of creativity. And yet something is missing to make this rendition a truly exciting and memorable artistic experience: call it heart and gravity. Always a master of brilliant visual set-pieces, Burton, no matter who he collaborates with as a scribe, is not a narrative storyteller in the conventional sense of the term." Emanuel Levy EMANUEL LEVY |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
"Climactic action setpiece, with an unlikely young warrior taking on a fearsome beast while gobs of CGI soldiers clash,
smacks of "The Lord of the Rings," "Harry Potter," "The Golden Compass," "The Chronicles of Narnia" and any number of other
such recent ventures. To be sure, the design, effects, makeup and technical work is of a high order. Other than Alice, the
most memorable characters are the wonderful hunting dog Bayard and the elusive Cheshire Cat, superbly voiced by Timothy
Spall and Stephen Fry, respectively. "You've lost your muchness," Johnny Depp's Mad Hatter remarks to his newly shrunken
teenage friend, and much the same could be said of Tim Burton in the wake of his encounter with a Victorian-era heroine of
imaginative powers even wilder than his own." Tod McCarthy VARIETY "Alice in Wonderland is a fun ride that you wouldn’t mind getting on once, but you’d hold off until the DVD to get on again. The performances are great, the music is fantastic, the visuals are polished, but the story is essentially the same. It’s the same Alice she’s just in a new outfit. But even though it’s not the greatest movie it’s still worth a viewing. Unlike most films that come out these days, the 3D element wasn’t the biggest selling point for Alice. It’s there, it’s present, but it’s not overwhelming." Krystal Clark SCREENCRAVE "While Alice in Wonderland generally dodges the indulgent pratfalls of several recent Burton films, there are still a few thorns that stuck out. Of these, the most incongruous was the inclusion of a baffling (and mercifully short-lived) dance sequence at the end of the film. At times, the plotting also feels rushed: perhaps as a result of tight editing to keep the runtime to a family-friendly length. Similarly the choice of Avril Lavigne's pop tune as the opening track of the end credits is bafflingly at odds with the mostly excellent Danny Elfman score. The transparent product licensing pulls the rug out from under Alice at the finish line." Patrick Kolan IGN AU "It should have been a case of a marriage made in heaven for the new fantasy blockbuster "Alice In Wonderland". While Wasikowska aquits herself brilliantly as Alice, the film often struggles to capture the right airs of wonder and magic that are key to her character's adventures. Overall, "Alice In Wonderland" works best when addressed as a throwaway eyepopper. The disappointment is that it could have been so much more. Leigh Paatsch HIT LITFOUT |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
Johnny Depp Mia Wasikowska Helena Bonham Carter Anne Hathaway Crispin Glover Matt Lucas Stephen Fry Christopher Lee Michael Sheen Alan Rickman Barbara Windsor Paul Whitehouse Timothy Spall Marton Csokas Tim Pigott-Smitht Lindsay Duncan Geraldine James Leo Bill Frances de la Tour Jemma Powell John Hopkins Eleanor Gecks Eleanor Tomlinson |
... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... |
Mad Hatter Alice Red Queen White Queen Knave of Hearts Tweedledee/Tweedledum Cheshire Cat Jabberwocky White Rabbit Blue Caterpillar Dormouse March Hare Bayard Charles Kingsleigh Lord Ascot Lady Ascot Helen Kingsleigh Hamish Aunt Imogene Margaret Kingsleigh Lowell Faith Chattaway Fiona Chattaway |
|
Director Screenplay Adapted Producers Original Music D.O.P. Film Editor Casting Production Designer Costume Designer |
... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... |
Tim Burton Linda Woolverton from the Lewis Carroll books "Alice's Adventures in Wonderland" "Through the Looking Glass" Tim Burton/Joe Roth/Jennifer Todd/Suzanne Todd Danny Elfman Dariusz Wolski Chris Lebenzon Susie Figgis Robert Stromberg Colleen Atwood |