
|
"The film increasingly short-changes the personal for the sake of the political, despite powerful scenes and another
impressive performance from Cillian Murphy." Matthew Leyland BBC "The Wind suffers from at least two problems. While paying tribute to the diversity of political discourse, not only between the British and the Irish, but also within the Irish themselves, the film ultimately reduces its complex debates to an interpersonal melodrama, in which two brothers are pitted against each other, a conventional format that trivializes the particular conflict." Emanuel Levy EMANUELLEVY.COM "Murphy is terrific in the central role and his softly spoken, essentially passive demeanour is used to powerful effect." Matthew Turner VIEWLONDON "If your sympathies are not with the Irish republicans, this film will irritate you, but so it should. If you are neutral on the subject, you'll get a buzz out of the sensitive filmmaking, superb, naturalistic performances with touches of improv, and a sense of outrage that informs the film's mood. It's good to get outraged about things, especially if you use that energy to make a film, instead of a bomb." Andrew L Urban URBAN CINEFILE "This is rough, edgy, honest filmmaking that doesn't shy away from the violent realities or the philosophical discussions. We feel the anguish and regret, the impossible decisions, desperate hope "that this is worth it". Although the Brits are basically just evil thugs, the Irish characters grapple with social justice in powerfully personal and complex ways. And Loach films it with a raw attention to detail that allows us to focus on the characters and the issues they're grappling with." Rich Cline SHADOW ON THE WALL |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
"The Wind that Shakes the Barley is set in Ireland in 1920, during the war for independence, also known as the war against
the "Black and Tans", and it's typical Loach, if not really vintage Loach. He has made better films, such as Riff-Raff,
Raining Stones, My Name is Joe, Kes and Ladybird, Ladybird, but this one has a powerful, emotional story to tell, with
strong overtones in current events. That is probably why he and the writer, Paul Laverty, chose to make it now." Paul Byrnes THE SYDNEY MORNING HERLAD "History is desperately important if we are to learn from our mistakes, and films that dredge that harbour are always useful, even if they take sides. Ken Loach takes the side of the Irish republicans who wouldn't settle for anything less than total independence from the Brits in 1920. A treaty - forged after bloody battles and skirmishes in a vicious guerrilla war - under which they had to still swear allegiance to the Crown seemed no victory at all." Andrew L Urban URBAN CINEFILE "Here, sadly, the focus on big issues hasn't left enough room for the smaller, spontaneous details that make Loach's finest films so intensely engaging." Matthew Leyland BBC "Though tastily lensed by ace d.p. Barry Ackroyd and with a convincing cast led by Cillian Murphy, essentially small-scale pic lacks the involving sweep of Loach's earlier historical-political yarn, "Land and Freedom," and looks likely to reap only modest returns in general arenas." Derek Elley VARIETY CANNES 2006 "Loach provides plenty of time for arguments on all sides of the political issue, and while that is important, those scenes slow down the film badly. He stages the many action sequences with assurance, however, and draws persuasive performances from his cast. With his poet's cheekbones and blue eyes, Murphy makes a fine romantic hero, and Delaney is a match as his duty-bound brother. Liam Cunningham, too, stands out as a thoughtful train driver-turned-rebel." Ray Bennett THE HOLLYWOOD REPORTER |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |